that is a big difference. i would say try a thermostat and not a dimmer. unplug everything and let it cool down so it is all the room same temp. plug it into the new thermostat and plug in thermostat. let it run for a few days and ur temps should be pretty close.
i built a hatchling rack with heattape and mine is a bit off. i have the Helix set for 93 and the center is 97 and the outsides are 93, i just turned it down a bit and ill be checking it again