Re: paper based substrate
The CareFresh bedding smells weird to me - sort of like feet or garbage. Not exactly sure what that smell is. It's pricey, too (at least in this area). I'll just stick with aspen.
Re: paper based substrate
I have been experimenting with Carefresh for a couple of months now. It is great for humidity. It is very absorbant. The problem I have recently discovered is that it doesn't absorb the smells. It doesn't smell like anything to me until it soaks up something. Other than that it's a fine substrate.