What do you say to the people who give you flak for cropping and docking?

[starmom]

I'm rediculously in love with Rots and when I get one I do plan to have the tail cropped, which suprises most people that I know. As I'm an animal lover they all assume I would think it cruel.

I say the same thing, that it's selfish on my part but it just looks better and I don't want that massive tail beating on my anemic little legs. I have enough mystery bruises already.

To be honest I know nothing about how it's done though, so I do hope that it is done humanely.

The only dog I've had so far was a german shepard and I wish his damn tail had been cut off. lol

I have a Rottie and he has his tail and my legs have never been bruised. Also, I do not agree that the tail is 'massive'. I think that it is a little silly to cosmetically enhance the (subjective) look of dogs. Can you not love Rottie's with their tails intact????

[dizzy]

Of course I would love a Rot tale or no tail! They're the sweetest, cutest dogs. But I do think their tails would end up breaking alot of stuff and giving me alot of bruises. They're large muscular dogs and as such I think they probably have alot of power in their wag. I can't say for sure having never owned one, and all the ones I've been around being cropped... I'm just making an assumption here... But I do bruise very easily. lol

When I do one day get my rot I am hoping to be able to adopt one from a shelter or rescue, so the odds are that it'll be cropped already. If for some reason I ended up getting a rot that wasn't cropped, I probably wouldn't have the heart to have it done, honestly. Especially since it would probably be older than the age it's typicaly done at.

I'm just saying that I'm not opposed to it and do prefer the look, though I know and stated that it is selfish on my part. But it's not a decision I'll likely have to make. Shelter doggie for me, please!

[DMTWI]

just ask them if their boys are circumcized. and thats their KID. you can do whatever you want to your dog, the vet wouldn't do it if it wasn't humane.

I'm going to use this next time I'm asked about my dogs ears. Yup, don't remember the procedure at all I'll say. Buy they did a great job, here I'll show you..............

[pillowtalk6188]

Of course I would love a Rot tale or no tail! They're the sweetest, cutest dogs. But I do think their tails would end up breaking alot of stuff and giving me alot of bruises. They're large muscular dogs and as such I think they probably have alot of power in their wag. I can't say for sure having never owned one, and all the ones I've been around being cropped... I'm just making an assumption here... But I do bruise very easily. lol

When I do one day get my rot I am hoping to be able to adopt one from a shelter or rescue, so the odds are that it'll be cropped already. If for some reason I ended up getting a rot that wasn't cropped, I probably wouldn't have the heart to have it done, honestly. Especially since it would probably be older than the age it's typicaly done at.

I'm just saying that I'm not opposed to it and do prefer the look, though I know and stated that it is selfish on my part. But it's not a decision I'll likely have to make. Shelter doggie for me, please!

my b/f's dane can clear off a whole table with his tale, def don't keep breakables on tables that their tales can reach, there have many broken picture frames and spilled drinks.

[starmom]

Of course I would love a Rot tale or no tail! They're the sweetest, cutest dogs. But I do think their tails would end up breaking alot of stuff and giving me alot of bruises. They're large muscular dogs and as such I think they probably have alot of power in their wag. I can't say for sure having never owned one, and all the ones I've been around being cropped... I'm just making an assumption here... But I do bruise very easily. lol...

my b/f's dane can clear off a whole table with his tale, def don't keep breakables on tables that their tales can reach, there have many broken picture frames and spilled drinks.

As mentioned, I have a Rottie who has his tail and I can say that he has never bruised me or even the grandkids. His tail has never broken anything in my home. He does not have a 'wag of death'. His tail is not an issue.

Many countries are now advocating and requiring that breeders do not cut off the tails of Rottweilers. I agree with this

[Typical_08]

Ya know, I am reminded of some advise I gave our roommate today.

She was complaining because her young pup was chewing up her stuffed animals.

In response to her question on how to stop the behavior. "Pick them up off the floor."

I guess the same applies to the "super tail" debate.

Now about the bruising. I don't bruise very easily. But the wife bruises like a peach. Each person is different.

[wolfy-hound]

What works for one person isn't going to work for another. I used to bruise so easily that a friendly squeeze of a hand would leave marks on my arms. A thick tail whapping on my leg would leave bruises like baseballs.
I don't see how a missing tail really affects most dogs in the least, as long as it's done within the 3-7 days of birth. I've watched pups getting tails and dewclaws docked, and most were more distressed over being picked up than they were about having their appendage snipped off.
I never saw a pup yet that seemed distressed over NOT having a tail. They grow up with no tail, so how would they miss it? Yes, it's mostly a cosmetic procedure(unless it's done later in life because of injury), but it's not exactly a issue to the dog.

[blackcrystal22]

Especially since you are possibly planning on showing him, they have absolutely no right to speak about your animal. Your not abusing it or causing it harm, and the procedure is pretty painless, and I'm sure they have some type of ointment/painkiller to help with the pain.

Really, if they bother you about it, tell them that they obviously don't know what they are talking about and don't have a right to speak about it.

[starmom]

What works for one person isn't going to work for another. I used to bruise so easily that a friendly squeeze of a hand would leave marks on my arms. A thick tail whapping on my leg would leave bruises like baseballs.
I don't see how a missing tail really affects most dogs in the least, as long as it's done within the 3-7 days of birth. I've watched pups getting tails and dewclaws docked, and most were more distressed over being picked up than they were about having their appendage snipped off.
I never saw a pup yet that seemed distressed over NOT having a tail. They grow up with no tail, so how would they miss it? Yes, it's mostly a cosmetic procedure(unless it's done later in life because of injury), but it's not exactly a issue to the dog.

I honestly don't know why you think that a Rottie's tail would bruise anyone...

It is my opinion that the question is not: "Does the dog miss the tail that has been cut off for cosmetic reasons?" but rather "Is this the right thing to do to a dog and are the reasons for the action ethical and justified?"

[wolfy-hound]

I think ANY dog's tail can bruise some people. Why do you assume that because you don't get any bruises from your dog's tail that no one ever would get a bruise from a dog's tail? I've gotten bruises from tails before, not from rotties, because most the rotties I know don't have tails(stubby things, not tails), but other similar dogs, including mixes, or labs, or other larger sized breeds have indeed bruised my legs, and arms in some cases.
I'm not saying to dock a dog's tail to prevent bruising your legs, but still, it can happen, and tails do indeed swipe stuff off tables in some cases too.
Again, if it's someone choice to dock a pup's tail, and it's not illegil, then they should go for it. If you don't want to dock your dog's tail, then leave it.